Is "no comment" a good response? No, according to Priority Marketing, an agency whose PR team laid out the case in a strategy piece. Declining an interview does not make the story go away. It pushes the reporter toward other sources: a competitor, an adversary, an eyewitness, or public records such as emails and texts.
That is the whole argument in one paragraph, and it is worth sitting with, because the reasoning matters more than the advice. The agency's point is not that silence is rude. It is that silence is a vacuum, and vacuums get filled by whoever is willing to talk. For anyone building a strategy for handling press requests, that framing is the useful part.
Priority Marketing, which sells media training and messaging services to local business owners, nonprofits and community leaders, published the piece on its own site, so read it as a vendor making its case. But the mechanics it describes are the standard ones, and they hold up on their own.
Why do people say "no comment" in the first place?
The agency groups the reasons into three: people don't know what to say, they don't know how to say it, or they don't know if they're allowed to say anything. Add fear of the camera and distrust of the reporter, and you have the full list the piece offers.
Two of those three are preparation problems. A spokesperson who doesn't know what to say hasn't been briefed. One who doesn't know how to say it hasn't been trained. Only the third, the permission question, is a genuine constraint, and even there the piece argues it is narrower than most people assume.
What does "no comment" actually communicate?
Here is the detail other coverage of this topic tends to skip: the phrase doesn't even do the thing people use it for. As Priority Marketing puts it, saying "no comment" is not avoiding a comment. Media often quote individuals saying exactly that, so the words end up in print anyway.
The agency is careful about what the phrase implies. It does not imply guilt, the piece says. But some viewers or readers may speculate that the subject is hiding something. That is a measured claim, and a fair one: the risk isn't a verdict, it's a question mark in the reader's mind that someone else gets to answer.
What does the journalism side expect?
The piece leans on the Society of Professional Journalists' Code of Ethics, which requires journalists to "diligently provide fair opportunity for subjects of news coverage to respond to criticism or allegations of wrongdoing." Reporters are not legally required to request your comment. They are ethically expected to offer the chance.
Read that from the subject's side and the invitation looks different. If the outlet is already obligated to seek your response, declining doesn't remove you from the story. It removes your voice from it. The interview is the one window where an organization can correct facts that were, in the agency's words, misinterpreted, misstated, misunderstood or misconstrued.
What should you say instead?
The piece's practical core is the bridging technique, which it sources to PR Daily: acknowledge the reporter's question, then transition back to your key messages. PR Daily calls the bridge "a transition that takes you from the reporter's question to an answer that works best for you."
The agency's worked examples are the strongest part. In one, a reporter asks whether a park is safe after a child was hospitalized in a fall. The suggested response can't address the specific case, but confirms that equipment undergoes monthly safety checks by a certified inspector. In the second, a bookkeeper has been arrested for embezzlement. The response directs questions about the arrest to the sheriff's office, then states that the company requires criminal background checks and drug testing for all new hires.
That second example answers the real question hiding under the constraint. Companies often can't discuss pending litigation, but they can describe general procedures and policies. The strategy is not evasion. It is redirecting to what you can verify.
The piece also draws a bright line on interview conduct. Do share facts, demonstrate expertise, and be open and transparent. Don't speculate, offer personal viewpoints, or make inflammatory statements. Even polished executives prepare, the agency notes, so inexperienced spokespeople should plan for extra time.
What this means for anyone drafting a response plan
The lesson is structural, and it fits the advice in our Crisis Communications Plan: Build Yours Before You Need It: the decision about whether to speak gets made before the reporter calls, not during. If your only prepared answer is "no comment," you have prepared to be quoted saying nothing while competitors, adversaries and public records speak for you.
Priority Marketing ends its piece with a sales pitch, which is expected from an agency selling media training. Strip that out and what remains is a serviceable test for any response decision: if you stay silent, who fills the gap, and what will they say? If you can't answer that, you don't have a strategy yet. You have a reflex. This connects to our earlier piece, Press Release vs Media Pitch: Which Tool When.
